This is a swing and a miss for me.
I've vaped tons of Bowden's Mate which is probably the best example of this flavor profile.
Where Cloud Provisions goes wrong with this liquid is in the chocolate flavor. It tastes profoundly chalky, and it's just not the right kind of sweetness. Where Bowden's Mate is refined and realistic, Caleb is rough, overly mentholated, and artificial.
The menthol in this doesn't have that Andes' Mints sweetness that it needs. It's more of a Newport cigarette menthol.
I didn't taste any tobacco in this. Even if I did, I'm sure it would've disappointed.
It's a budget juice and I understand that. But it's no excuse to make subpar liquid.
Reviewed using: Tsunami RDA dual claptons .5 ohms