What a letdown.
I'm a fan of Dinner Lady's lemon tart. It's not my favorite juice of all time because I'm not a big fan of lemon vapes, but it is good, no denying it. It's not something I can vape every day and it's quite harsh first thing in the morning, but still good.
Mr. Meringue is disgusting. The packaging is nice. The juice gets 5 star reviews everywhere. It even smells nice. But, unfortunately, it's using one of those bad lemon flavorings that taste like dish soap. Yes, I have been steeping this for over a month. It's still nasty. If that's not bad enough, the "coconut" flavoring is not what you think it is. It's not a sweet coconut like you would expect in a pie, it is an earthy coconut. The type of coconut you get in sun tan lotion. Sun tan lotion and lemon scented dish soap. If that sounds good to you, you'll love this juice. If you are even remotely sensitive to lemon pledge flavored liquids you should avoid this juice like the plague.
Another thing that bothers me is the lack of sweetener. This is supposed to be a lemon meringue pie FFS. Where is the sweetness? Jesus Christ, if I made a lemon meringue pie and it turned out as bad as Mr. Meringue I would at the very least cover up the bad flavor with a ton of sweetener like some other premium juice companies do.
I have no idea how Charlie's Chalk Dust is such a popular juice company. I've tried 3 of their juices so far and reviewed 2. They were all awful. Not "ok", actually AWFUL. Not to mention overpriced.
This is a textbook example of good marketing, hype and good packaging covering up sub-par juice.
If you want a lemon pie / lemon tart type of juice go with Dinner Lady's lemon tart instead of this abomination.