I was excited to try this juice. I'm a sucker for cute packaging and this one totally fits the bill in that department with the adorable milk bottle cartons it comes in. I put it at a 3.5 because as I've said in the past many times, I don't usually like strawberry flavored juices, and while this one is definitely strawberry flavored, the pastry and cream flavor tone it down a bit so that it is much smoother. That being said, although the taste is quite good, I could only go through two tanks before I had to switch back to my usual custard juice because the sweetness of it was making me feel a little sick. I know for a lot of people Milkman is the holy grail of juices and I'm definitely going to try more of their flavors after having this (I also tried the sugar cookie one and the hazel, both of which I liked pretty well), I'm thinking of giving their Streudel flavor a try since it's supposed to be along the lines of a blueberries and cream flavor and I've found that I LOVE blueberry flavors in vape. I'll update once I try that one!