French Pipe by Grand Rapids E Liquid is good, but not one of my personal favorites. It taste like pipe tobacco, which for some is great and if you are looking for a vanilla pipe tobacco flavor, this one is absolutely for you. For me though, it was just a rough and strong pipe tobacco flavor. Since I honestly wasn't a heavy smoke, it was a little rough for me when I tried it. When I tried it, it was at a 50/50 blend on an Istick 30w with Subtank Nano. It had nice clouds, so that part I scored a 10. If you like pipe tobacco give it a try and post what you thought.